The Rabid Wolverine delivered an all-time classic against Triple H and Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania XX as well. Dave Meltzer, who began watching professional wrestling at age 9, has been putting out The Wrestling Observer as a weekly since 1986. Edge e Beth Phoenix: 4. 10 AEW Stars & Their Best Match, According To Dave Meltzer. David Allen Meltzer who is also known as Dave Meltzer is an American Journalist. The first match rated more than five stars by Meltzer was Ric Flair vs Ricky Steamboat in 1989. One post was them talking about how brainwashed some fans are and literally the next one I see is Big Dick Dave's ratings. Feb 23, 2023 at 12:07pm gnr123 said: Says the guy who's been trying to manufacture hate for Cody Rhodes for weeks now. Genius is the ultimate source of music knowledge, created by scholars like you who share facts and insight about the songs and artists they love. Unfortunately, the finish wasnt perfect, but it did set up more matches in the aftermath. The Big Boss Man vs Al Snow was one of those the latter. Meltzer retarded rating strikes once again. All original match ratings come from Dave Meltzer of the highly respected Wrestling Observer Newsletter. This list will examine 10 forgotten WCW matches that received very low marks (all receiving a less than 0 rating) from Dave Meltzer on his 5-star scale. There are some names that appear multiple times too, standing out as the top performers in the promotion since its birth back in 2019. Perhaps 5 stars was a little too much for a match which had a predictable winner, but their fluidity and impressive spots are well worth the acclaim that this bout received, adding a classic to Omegas great title reign. Bret and Owen Hart are two of all-time greats to ever lace a pair of boots inside the squared circle. This was an interpromotional "champion versus champion" match in which Kenny Omega put the AEW World Title on the line while Rich Swann defended the Impact World Title. A five-star match should be exceptional, flawless, perfect, a masterpiece, simply an all-time classic. Andrew Kelly is a writer from The Wirral, England. Wrestling Observer Radio: UFC 281, SmackDown . Len Denton's book is a fantastic read through the territory days of professional wrestling, and he's not shy about his personal failures, either. The Lucha Brothers picked up the victory to a huge reaction too. Wrestling Book by Lynn Denton and Joe Vithayathil. The match is a five-star classic in the eyes of many fans. Kurt Angle vs Jeff Hardy at No . The star ratings Meltzer gives to matches is widely debated among fans, especially his more . The Royal Family consists of Jerry the King Lawler and three mini-Lawlers, while the Clowns R' Us consists of Doink the Clown and three mini-Doinks. Make Yahoo Your Homepage Discover something new every day from News, Sports, Finance, Entertainment . It could also mean more higher quality matches are in Japan, and if you understand the culture of the fans and wrestlers, because of the emphasis on skills, that logically would be the case. this is a great book if your interested in the people behind the brutal and often sad world . At WWE, the Boogeyman spent most of his time scaring other contestants and from time to time placing worms inside the mouths of his opponents. Apart from being one of the most hated heels in the WWE, Roddy Piper was involved in some of the highest-rated interview segments. This match would be perfectly fine with four stars. Dave has rated thousands and thousands of match on a scale of 0-5 (or higher) since the very first edition of the Observer came out, and his scores are still highly regarded and coveted by those in the industry. There were several death-defying spots, particularly from Guevara who delivered a scary swanton bomb from atop a ladder, and an insane springboard cutter from a ladder too, which brought the audience to their feet. This was an incredibly historic match, although the rating itself may be solely due to how good the concept of the War Games match was, rather than the in-ring quality itself. It was arguably their greatest match, and Dave Meltzer awarded the historic match 4.75 stars. Meltzer rated the match 4.75 stars. 5* | Sat, Oct 21st 2017 | PWG All Star Weekend 13 - Night 2 | WALTER vs. Zack Sabre Jr. 5* | Sun, Sep 3rd 2017 | PWG Battle Of Los Angeles 2017 - Day 3 | Keith Lee vs. Donovan Dijak, 5* | Fri, Aug 11th 2017 | NJPW G1 Climax 2017 - Day 17 | Tetsuya Naito vs. Hiroshi Tanahashi, 5* | Sat, Jun 3rd 2017 | NJPW Best Of The Super Juniors 2017 - Day 14 | KUSHIDA vs. Will Ospreay, 5* | Sun, Apr 9th 2017 | NJPW Sakura Genesis | Kazuchika Okada vs. Katsuyori Shibata, 5* | Sat, Feb 11th 2017 | NJPW The New Beginning In Osaka | Tetsuya Naito vs. Michael Elgin, 5* | Sat, Sep 3rd 2016 | PWG Battle Of Los Angeles 2016 - Night 2 | Will Ospreay, Ricochet, Matt Sydal vs. Nick Jackson, Adam Cole, Matt Jackson (6-Man Tag), 5* | Sat, Aug 13th 2016 | NJPW G1 Climax 26 | Kenny Omega vs. Tetsuya Naito, 5* | Sat, Aug 6th 2016 NJPW G1 Climax 26 | Tomohiro Ishii vs. Kazuchika Okada, 5* | Mon, Jan 4th 2016 | NJPW Wrestle Kingdom 10 | Kazuchika Okada vs. Hiroshi Tanahashi, 5* | Sun, Aug 16th 2015 | NJPW G1 Climax 25 | Hiroshi Tanahashi vs. Shinsuke Nakamura, 5* | Sat, Feb 14th 2015 | NJPW The New Beginning In Sendai '15 | Tomohiro Ishii vs. Tomoaki Honma, 5* | Sun, Jan 4th 2015 | NJPW Wrestle Kingdom 9 | Shinsuke Nakamura vs. Kota Ibushi, 5* | Sun, Sep 21st 2014 | NJPW Destruction In Kobe '14 | Hiroshi Tanahashi vs. Katsuyori Shibata, 5* | Mon, Oct 14th 2013 | NJPW King Of Pro Wrestling '13 | Kazuchika Okada vs. Hiroshi Tanahashi, 5* | Sat, Aug 3rd 2013 | NJPW G1 Climax 23 | Tomohiro Ishii vs. Katsuyori Shibata, 5* | Sat, Apr 6th 2013 | NJPW Invasion Attack | Kazuchika Okada vs. Hiroshi Tanahashi, 5* | Mon, Oct 8th 2012 | NJPW King Of Pro Wrestling | Hiroshi Tanahashi vs. Minoru Suzuki, 5* | Sat, Mar 31st 2012 | ROH Showdown In The Sun | Davey Richards vs. Michael Elgin, 5* | Sun, Jul 17th 2011 | WWE Money In The Bank | C. M. Punk vs. John Cena, 5* | Fri, Mar 31st 2006 | ROH Supercard Of Honor | Ryo Saito, Dragon Kid, Genki Horiguchi CIMA, Naruki Doi, Masato Yoshino (6-Man Tag), 5* | Sat, Oct 1st 2005 | ROH |Kenta Kobashi vs. Samoa Joe, 5* | Sun, Sep 11th 2005 | TNA Unbreakable | A.J. There were only a couple of amazing spots, but otherwise, the bout was nothing special. Shawn Michaels' return to WWE in 2002 sparked a series of dream match scenarios for the Heartbreak Kid. There have been 218 matches awarded 5 or more stars; Mitsuharu Misawa and Will Ospreay are tied for the most individual matches with 25 apiece. RELATED: Kenny Omega's 10 Best Matches, According To Dave Meltzer Flair is undoubtedly one of the greatest of all time, and although his career has gone on far longer than it should (on more than . AJ Styles made his WWE debut at Royal Rumble 2016. Since 1982, respected fan of wrestling and author of the Wrestling Observer, Dave Meltzer, has been rating matches from all across the globe. On September 4, 2021, Jeff Cobb scored one of the biggest wins of his career by defeating Kazuchika Okada in a great bout, but it was nothing extraordinary as Dave Meltzer thinks it was. Jim Wilson/The . The World's Most Entertaining Car Website. By Dave Meltzer Nov 24, 2022. Following their one-hour time limit draw, this was a much-anticipated rematch between Adam Page and Bryan Danielson. Without further ado, let's take a look at 10 wrestling matches that Dave Meltzer has over rated. It was compiled by Dave Meltzer and published in the wrestling observer in 2008. While some of the jokes in this match worked, the rest fell flat. The World's Most Entertaining Car Website. However, that anticlimactic ending was the main reason this match shouldn't be rated higher than three and a half stars. The two superstars told an incredible story as they stayed inside the ring for the whole duration of the match. It was bloody, violent, and creative with many scary looking spots and hard-hitting bumps, including a crazy leap from Rey Fenix off the top of the cage. Currently unavailable. Amongst their classic trilogy, Steamboat and Flair worked the house show circuit, with this match in March standing out as one of the few matches to break Dave Meltzers 5 Star Rating, by achieving an astonishing 6 Stars. The trilogy of classics between these two all offered something different, with fan opinion varying on which is their favorite, but this was certainly the most decisive of the three in terms of finish. He rates them on a 5-star scale [here are all of the five-star ratings that he has ever given out]. On AEW's first night Cody and Dustin Rhodes undoubtedly stole the show as Dustin put on a career-defining show. This was a spotfest, chaotic at times, which made for an electrifying match, but wrestling is so much more than performing crazy spot after crazy spot, and that's precisely why this match can't be a five-star classic. Styles vs. Christopher Daniels vs Samoa Joe (Triple-Threat), 5* | Sat, Oct 16th 2004 | ROH | Samoa Joe vs. C. M. Punk, 5* | Sat, Jul 10th 2004 | NOAH Departure '04 | Kenta Kobashi vs. Jun Akiyama, 5* | Sat, Mar 1st 2003 | NOAH Navigate For Evolution '03 | Kenta Kobashi vs. Mitsuharu Misawa, 5* | Fri, Jun 11th 1999 | AJPW Budokan Hall Show | Mitsuharu Misawa vs. Kenta Kobashi, 5* | Sat, Oct 31st 1998 | AJPW 26th Anniversary Show | Mitsuharu Misawa vs. Kenta Kobashi, 5* | Fri, Dec 5th 1997 | AJPW Budokan Hall Show | Akira Taue, Toshiaki Kawada, Jun Akiyama, Mitsuharu Misawa, 5* | Sun, Oct 5th 1997 | WWF In Your House 18: Badd Blood | Shawn Michaels vs. Despite its overall influence, the match only got three stars from Dave Meltzer. Dave Meltzer clarified Omega's contract status in this week's Wrestling Observer Newsletter (subscription required), explaining that it had indeed been extended but there was uncertainty as to exactly how long. Wrestling Junkie Staff. On top of that, the two wrestlers failed to show any work rate or heart. From Episode 196 of Jim Cornette's Drive ThruArtwork by Travis Heckel!Send in your question for the Drive-Thru to: CornyDriveThru@gmail.com Follow Jim and Br. Writing in the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, Dave Meltzer stated that the switch came as WrestleMania is about "marquee matches.". John Cena vs John Laurinaitis - Over the Limit 2012 (0.80 Rating) Starting the list if a match between a man who has received a five star match from Dave Meltzer, and John Cena. The triple threat bout showcased the three ring generals in their prime and is cited as one of the greatest 'Mania main events of all time. Bryan Danielson put together one of . The iconic stables arrival in WWE led to one of the greatest matches in wrestling history. The match cemented Hunter as a main-eventer for years to come and preserved Foleys legacy as a star maker. That said, his wrestling career is stacked with classics against the likes of 2 Cold Scorpio, Bret Hart, Eddie Guerrero, and other greats of the business. Mick Foley made stars out of a myriad of performers including Triple H, who became a solidified main-eventer after this barbaric rivalry with Mrs. Foleys baby boy. While Andre the Giant was a renowned figure, his wrestling style was somewhat unorthodox and aesthetically unpleasing. This had a mixture of great mat wrestling, stiff blows, and a whole of other great action in between, which ended with Steamboat winning the title after a shocking roll-up, but it felt like the perfect way for the belt to change hands. For more information, please see our Without further delay, here are the 10 worst wrestling matches according to Dave Meltzer. An unsurprising start, The Nature Boy was part of the unofficial first 5 star Meltzer match when he took on Butch Reed at a Florida wrestling event in 1982. Since the G1 Climax finale, Osprey has been on an absolute tear, wrestling a pair of matches in the UK's RevPro versus "Speedball" Mike Bayley and Ricky Knight Jr. - who fans may know as . To date he has rated 208 matches five stars (or above). Obviously, this match meant a lot and generated high expectations. 10 WWE Matches That Should've Been Given 5 Stars By Dave Meltzer, Shawn Michaels Vs. Mankind (In Your House 10: Mind Games), Triple H Vs. Cactus Jack (Royal Rumble 2000), The Rock Vs. Hulk Hogan (WrestleMania X8), Chris Benoit & Kurt Angle vs. In the main event of Fastlane 2016, Brock Lesnar, Roman Reigns, and Dean Ambrose collided in a triple threat match. Unique lists featuring pop culture, entertainment and crazy facts. Top 10 Wrestlemanias based on Dave Meltzer Ratings. Windham put on a great babyface performance, giving Flair his comeuppance for his sneaky and cowardly heel tactics, whilst also fighting through the blood and pain he was being put through. ", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2019)", "Dave Meltzer on Twitter: "Atlanta War Games was *****", "In Search of Five Star Matches Part Two", "In 1989, Flair & Steamboat did 10.25 stars working an afternoon and evening show in Landover & Philly on house shows", "August 21, 1991 Observer Newsletter More WWF steroid troubles, Billy Graham lawsuit", "Hall of Fame season: The best matches of Akira Taue", "February 25, 1991 Wrestling Observer Newsletter Full Wrestlemania card released", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2019) Page 2 of 6", "Jan. 17 1994 Observer Newsletter: The 1993 Wrestling Observer Reader Awards issue", "May 10, 1993 Observer Newsletter: Konnan retires, Hogan buries WWF, Heyman new promotion, tons more", "August 30, 1993 Observer Newsletter: Wrestling recovery?, Terry Gordy collapses,Gene Okerlund leaves WWE", "April 19, 1993 Observer Newsletter: Von Erich death fallout, Hogan title update, Mania buyrate, more", "March 7, 1994 Observer Newsletter: Lawler case finished, WWE leaks finish that didn't end up the finish", "March 21, 1994 Observer Newsletter: Tonya Harding and wrestling, Hogan/WCW, Mania X preview, more", "Wrestling Observer Radio: Vince McMahon is back, Dana White, Omega vs. Ospreay", "August 8, 1994 Observer Newsletter: Back to business after trial, a huge week for pro-wrestling internationally, new promotion starting up, tons more", "Dec. 19, 1994 Observer Newsletter: Epic Rickson Gracie vs. Yoji Anjoh story which ultimately led to the creation of PRIDE, UFC IV set, Real World Tag League tournament, tons more", "Jan. 30, 1995 Observer Newsletter: 1995 Royal Rumble, angle to bring Ric Flair back to WCW, "Nu Jack" legal issues, business trends of past three years, more", "Oct. 23, 1995 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: Bill Watts already gone from WWE after three weeks, New Japan/UWFi update, Ultimate Ultimate tournament pairings, tons more", "Jan. 22, 1996 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: Results of the 1995 Observer Newsletter Awards, 1995 Record Book, tons more", "Jan. 13, 1997 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: 1997 Annual Awards Issue, a look at all the major shows of the year, tons more", "Nov. 11, 1996 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: Infamous angle where Austin broke into Pillman's house, thoughts on Hall of Fame issue, Pancrase PPV, tons more", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2019) Page 3 of 6", "August 3, 1998 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: More on Leno and WCW, WWF Fully Loaded review, death of June Byers, more", "November 15, 1999 Wrestling Observer Newsletter: ECW November to Remember review, Dynamite Kid book, more", "JANUARY 1, 2001 WRESTLING OBSERVER NEWSLETTER: CANDIDATES FOR WRESTLER OF THE YEAR, SAKURABA DEFEATS ANOTHER GRACIE, MORE", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2019) Page 4 of 6", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2019) Page 5 of 6", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2020) Page 6 of 6", "Dave Meltzer 5 Star Matches List (1983 to 2021) - Page 7", "Will Ospreay vs Ricky Knight Jr Awarded 5 Star Rating By Dave Meltzer", "Will Ospreay Awarded TWO Five Star Matches In One Week", "Dutch Mantell sugiere a WWE preste mayor atencin al uso de Gunther", "EVERY DAVE MELTZER 5-STAR RATING OF 2022", "Every Dave Meltzer 5-Star Rating of 2023", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=List_of_professional_wrestling_matches_rated_5_or_more_stars_by_Dave_Meltzer&oldid=1141058165, This page was last edited on 23 February 2023, at 03:54. 4.0 out of 5 stars 24. He is considered as one of the top journalists in the entertainment industry and is majorly known for covering professional wrestling and mixed martial arts. Wrestling Observer Radio. In an era filled with strange rules and regulations, the Moondog Spot vs Junkyard bout has to be the weirdest of all time.